Showing posts with label Racism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Racism. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 27, 2009

Aslan, the Racist Lion


I've always sort of assumed that the Narnia Chronicles - while fabulous and fun to read - are a bit on the racist end of literature. I'm open to people disagreeing - which is part why I post this - because I don't think I've ever "talked this one out", except with a rather disagreeable young man who thought that Lewis was probably right to "stick it" to the darkies because Islam (particularly) is something to fear, abhor - and perhaps even assail. This has not become a fruitful relationship.

Throughout the Narnia stories a race of avowed enemies (the only comparable/consistent nemesis would be the Witch, Lewis' devil) are the Calormemes of Calormen, a region of desert people who wear turbans, baggy trousers and pointy shoes. They arrange marriages, put the symbol of the crescent on their money, fight with scimitars and - in The Last Battle - are even referred to as "darkies". Friends, with a little poco-muscle there are oodles of dissertations buried here.

I think this is pretty clear, but I'm not sure it takes away from my love of the stories themselves, though I wouldn't want my children to read The Horse and His Boy. After all, I love and revere writers, thinkers and public figures who had far from enlightened racial perspectives - among them Abraham Kuyper. But should we be more attentive how we read - what are obviously very broken and sinful racial constructs - through our history and literature?